Blockchain nodes – Shared, semi-shared, or dedicated nodes

The blockchain landscape has seen incredible changes in the last decade. Companies and individuals alike are more interested than ever in leveraging blockchain technology for various applications and services. One of the critical decisions to make while building or utilizing blockchain services is choosing the right type of node. The options? Shared, semi-shared, or dedicated nodes – which one to choose? In this article, we will explore these options to help you make the right decision.

What are blockchain nodes?

Blockchain nodes are the pillars that uphold the integrity and functionality of a blockchain network. These internet-connected devices execute key roles, from validating and verifying transactions to maintaining an accurate ledger. Whenever a transaction occurs, it is disseminated across all nodes to ensure network consensus and security.

Types of nodes on the blockchain

Shared nodes

Shared nodes are the most budget-friendly option, where multiple users share the resources and computing power of a single node. This arrangement drastically reduces individual costs and offers a quick way to access blockchain networks without any setup hassles. However, the downside is that you’re essentially sharing resources with other users, which can sometimes lead to performance bottlenecks and potential security vulnerabilities, particularly if one of the “neighbors” engages in malicious activities.

Semi-shared nodes

Serving as a middle-ground between shared and dedicated nodes, semi-shared nodes are used by a limited number of users. This helps mitigate the performance limitations seen in fully shared nodes. Costs are higher than shared nodes but significantly lower than running a dedicated node. Semi-shared nodes can offer a balance between performance and cost, making them a suitable choice for medium-scale projects that require more reliability but still have budget constraints.

Dedicated nodes

These are the premium choices for businesses and projects that require high performance, security, and full control over the node’s settings. A dedicated node is exclusively used by a single entity, ensuring that all resources are solely allocated for its activities. While this comes with higher costs and a requirement for maintenance, the benefits include robust security measures, customizable settings, and the ability to handle higher transaction volumes without any performance issues.

Each type of node presents its own set of advantages and drawbacks, making it crucial to assess your specific needs, performance requirements, and budget considerations before making a choice. By understanding these aspects, you can select the node type that is the most appropriate for your blockchain journey.

Shared nodes

When diving into the blockchain ecosystem, choosing the right type of node is crucial for ensuring optimal performance, security, and cost-efficiency. Shared nodes serve as an accessible entry point for many, offering a range of benefits while also coming with some drawbacks. Here’s a more detailed look.

Pros of using shared nodes

• Cost-Effective: One of the primary advantages of using shared nodes is the reduced financial burden. Because multiple users or projects share the same node, the overall operational costs get distributed. This makes shared nodes the most budget-friendly option, particularly appealing for startups or individual developers.
• Ease of Use: Setting up and maintaining a node can be technically challenging. Shared nodes simplify this process by offering a plug-and-play experience. They are often managed by third-party providers, which means users don’t need to worry about complicated setup or maintenance—making them ideal for blockchain beginners or projects that have minimal technical resources.

Cons of using shared nodes

• Limited resources: One of the primary drawbacks of shared nodes is the division of computational power, memory, and bandwidth among multiple users. This can result in slower transaction validation times and reduced overall performance, especially during peak usage times. For projects that require high-throughput and quick confirmations, this limitation can be a significant hurdle.
• Security risks: Shared nodes are more susceptible to various security issues, particularly the risk of “bad neighbors.” Since multiple users have access to the node, there’s a chance that one of them could engage in malicious activities, compromising the security and integrity of the node for everyone else. Extra caution and due diligence are advised when selecting a third-party shared node provider to mitigate these risks.
• Lack of customization: Unlike dedicated nodes, shared nodes offer limited customization options. The configurations are often predetermined by the service provider, leaving users with little to no flexibility to tailor the node settings according to their specific requirements.

In summary, shared nodes can serve as an excellent starting point for smaller projects or individuals looking to venture into the blockchain space without committing substantial financial and technical resources. However, it’s crucial to weigh the pros and cons carefully to determine if a shared node aligns with your project’s long-term objectives and requirements.

Semi-shared nodes

When it comes to selecting a node type for your blockchain project, the choice isn’t always black and white. Situated between the shared and dedicated node options, semi-shared nodes offer a balanced solution. They combine elements of both, aiming to deliver better performance without breaking the bank. Let’s explore their pros and cons in greater detail:

Pros of using semi-shared nodes

• Moderate cost: Semi-shared nodes offer a middle-ground financial solution, being more affordable than dedicated nodes but slightly more expensive than shared nodes. This makes them a viable option for small to medium enterprises (SMEs) or developers who have a moderate budget but still want to avoid the limitations of shared nodes.
• Balanced resources: With fewer users sharing the resources, semi-shared nodes typically offer better performance than fully shared nodes. This can be particularly beneficial for projects that require faster transaction validation or higher computational power but don’t have the budget for a dedicated node.

Cons of using semi-shared nodes

• Variable performance: While they offer better performance compared to shared nodes, semi-shared nodes can still experience fluctuating performance levels. This is because the activities of other users on the same node can impact your project’s efficiency and speed. It’s a compromise between the consistency of dedicated nodes and the unpredictability of shared nodes.
• Limited customization: Although semi-shared nodes may offer some level of configurability, they don’t provide the full spectrum of customization options that dedicated nodes do. This means that users may have to adapt their projects to the existing configurations, which could be restrictive depending on the specific requirements of your blockchain application.
• Shared security risks: While less pronounced than in fully shared nodes, semi-shared nodes still bear some security risks. Users still share resources on these nodes. This can lead to security risks from “bad neighbors.” However, fewer users share the system compared to fully shared nodes. This reduces the overall risk. The security is better than on shared nodes, but not as good as on dedicated ones. Users must weigh the balance between cost and security when choosing.

In conclusion, semi-shared nodes offer a balanced approach, ideal for those who seek a compromise between cost, performance, and customization. While they aren’t a one-size-fits-all solution, they fill an important niche, offering a middle path for projects that have outgrown shared nodes but aren’t quite ready for the financial and technical commitment of a dedicated node.

Dedicated nodes

For enterprises and large-scale blockchain projects that require the highest levels of control, security, and performance, dedicated nodes are often the go-to choice. These nodes are exclusively used by a single entity, providing a range of advantages but also coming with their set of challenges. Let’s break down their pros and cons:

Pros of Using Dedicated Nodes

• Full control: One of the most compelling advantages of using a dedicated node is the level of control it offers. Users can customize settings to fit the exact requirements of their blockchain project, from transaction validation rules to security protocols. This flexibility can be invaluable for projects with specific or complex needs.
• High performance: With no sharing of computational resources, memory, or bandwidth, dedicated nodes offer peak performance. This ensures quick transaction validations, high throughput, and overall improved efficiency—qualities that are essential for large-scale or mission-critical blockchain applications.

Cons of using dedicated nodes

• Costly: The flip side of having exclusive access to a node’s resources is the cost. Dedicated nodes require a substantial financial investment not just in the setup but also in the ongoing maintenance. This makes them less ideal for startups or smaller projects operating on a limited budget.
• Maintenance requirements: Unlike shared or semi-shared nodes that are often managed by a third-party provider, dedicated nodes usually require regular monitoring and updates. This means an additional investment in human resources or specialized software to keep the node secure and operational. Failure to regularly update and monitor the node can lead to security vulnerabilities or performance issues.
• Technical expertise: Operating a dedicated node often requires a level of technical expertise that goes beyond the plug-and-play experience offered by shared or semi-shared options. This might necessitate a dedicated IT team or specialized blockchain developers, adding another layer of cost and complexity to your project.

Which blockchain node to choose?

Choosing the right type of node for your blockchain project can be a pivotal decision. The choice often depends on various factors, including the scale of the project, its performance requirements, budget constraints, and the level of expertise available. Here’s a guideline to help you select the most appropriate node type based on different use cases:

Small Projects & Learning

• Recommended Option: Shared Nodes
  Shared nodes offer an ideal entry point for small-scale projects, prototypes, or newcomers to the blockchain space. These nodes suit developers who are just starting out or testing ideas. They provide an affordable way to begin working with blockchain technology without a large upfront investment.
• Why Choose This: Cost-efficiency is a major factor for small projects. Shared nodes offer an economical way to access blockchain networks without any complex setup.
• Considerations: However, be mindful of the limited resources and potential security risks. Shared nodes are a learning curve but are not recommended for high-stakes applications.

Medium Scale Projects

• Recommended Option: Semi-Shared Nodes
  Semi-shared nodes often provide a comfortable middle ground for projects that have grown beyond the startup phase or individual learning but haven’t yet become full-fledged enterprises.
• Why Choose This: A balanced approach between cost and performance is what makes semi-shared nodes attractive. They offer improved performance over shared nodes, without the hefty price tag associated with dedicated nodes.
• Considerations: While they do offer better performance, the customization options are limited, and performance can still vary based on other users sharing the node.

Enterprise Level or High-Stake Operations

• Recommended Option: Dedicated Nodes
  For large-scale projects, enterprise-level operations, or any scenarios where the stakes are high, a dedicated node is the recommended option
• Why Choose This: Dedicated nodes offer unmatched performance, control, and security. These factors are crucial for projects that handle a high volume of transactions, possess sensitive data, or require specialized configurations.
• Considerations: The cost and maintenance requirements are significant, necessitating a dedicated team and budget. It’s an investment that should align with the project’s long-term goals and operational scale.

In conclusion, the node type you choose should align closely with the requirements and constraints of your specific use case.

Shared, semi-shared, or dedicated nodes – which one is the best?

Your choice between shared, semi-shared, and dedicated nodes should align with your project’s specific needs, scale, and budget. Each has its own set of pros and cons, and understanding these will guide you in your blockchain journey.

Read more about CoinAPI’s Node-as-a-Service